"Duk perevilled": Fim na tarihi, gurbata ainihin tushen tarihi

Anonim
"Ƙarfin zuciya" (1995)

Yanayi: Randall Wallace

Abin mamaki na Mala Gibson akan dawakai

An san shi da banbancin tarihi, labarin game da Scottish Wallace kawai yana haɓaka da matsaloli. Da farko, sunan barkwanci "zuciya mai ƙarfin zuciya" nasa Robert Bruce (wanda yake mai cin nasara ne a cikin fim). Haka ne, kuma babu wanda ya warke a lokacin. Abu na biyu, Wallace ba a haife ta da talauci ba, kamar yadda fim ya nuna. Bai kasance kusa da Sarauniya Sheabelle ba, ba a ambaci cewa wasu haɗin da ita ba. Kuma mafi yawan kuskuren fim shine rashin gada a kan sanannen yaƙi a kan babban gadar.

"Yu-571" (2000)

Yanayi: Dauda Air

Saurayi Matiyu McConisa

Mahimmancin fim din game da yakin duniya na II ya danganta da karbar injin injuna a maimakon Ingila. Wannan matakin shine tsarkakakkiyar kasuwanci, amma yana da sakamako mai nisa. Firayim Ministan Burtaniya Tony Blair ya kira wannan "zagi tunanin" na yakin masu mahalarta, da kuma Bill Clinton ya karfafa harafin da aka jaddada wasika. Har da iska, wanda da kansa ya sauya abubuwan da suka faru na tarihi a matsayin motocin sa, "angonana da kakana ya yi ta jingina su ne ya gurbata su."

"Shekaru 10,000 BC" " (2008)

Scensio: Roland Emmerich da Harald Klozer

Magazin na Magajin mujallar Magazin mujallar mujallar mujallata game da wannan fim kamar haka: "Ba abin mamaki bane cewa wannan kabila tana fama da farauta, saboda kowane al'adun da ke ƙoƙarin farautar dabbobi masu shayarwa, da kuma hanyar sadarwa ta cancanci." Kusan duk abin da ke ciki shine rashin tsari, idan kun yi la'akari da sunan suna magana da aikin a fim ɗin yana faruwa shekaru dubu 10 kafin zamaninmu. Dabbobin dabbobi da waɗanda ba su canzawa ba tukuna, roam anan da can. Wani mutum yana koyar da Mammoth. Saiteboats sun kasance a cikin millennia gabaɗaya daga bayyanar. Cats-cats-cats ba girman hippopots ba!

"Patriot" (2000)

Yanayi: Robert Lodat

Patriot Mela Gibson ba ya ce labarin gaskiya, amma yana nuna abubuwan tarihi wanda cikakkun bayanai suka gurbata. Benjamin Martin ya kasance mai kisa ne kuma mai rusa, kuma ba wasu jarumin mulkin mallaka ba. Birtaniyya a fim din aikata kisan-kiyashi, wanda a zahiri bai kasance, ƙona mutane ba da rai a cikin cocin, alal misali. Da kyau, a kan kasancewar bautar a cikin wannan epoch, da allo kuma rufe idanunsu.

Learl Harbor (2001)

Yanayi: Randall Wallace

Sake wallace. A wannan karon, rubutun zuciyar "jarumi" ya kusanci rubuta "Pearl tashar jiragen ruwa" kamar rubuta rubutun don wasu jerin CW. Wallace ta sake bayyana labarin na gaske na ainihi na sojoji, kodayake sunaye kawai suna da gaske a can. Ayyukansu da rayuwar sirri da alama an ɗauke su daga wasan kwaikwayon sabulu ko fim ɗin kuɗi na biyu. Hakanan hoton gidan Jafananci kuma an gurbata - a zanen da ake nuna su ta hanyar son rai svines. Gabaɗaya, kawai abin da aka nuna a cikin fim, a zahiri.

"Apocalypse" (2006)

Yanayi: Mel Gibson da Farrad Safia

Fim na uku a cikin wannan jerin wanda Mel Gibson ya bayyana. Yayi kama da yana so ya rubuta nasa labarin. Wadanda abin ya shafa a wannan lokacin - tsohuwar Maya. Kamar yadda aka nuna a cikin "Apocalypse", a Janar, mutane masu zaman lafiya sun kasance masu tayar da hankali da jini, kodayake bincike da kuma rahoton masana kimiyya suna nuna cewa Maya galibi manoma ne.

"Inchlastic bastards" (2009)

Yanayi: Quardin Tarantino

Quntin kawai ya yi amfani da yakin duniya na biyu a matsayin wani abu don "kayan abinci mai amfani." Bai yi ƙoƙarin faɗi gaskiya ba. Eleriler: A gaskiya, Hitler, ba shakka, ba ya son Tarantino, kashe a cikin sinima.

"Wasannin Tunani" (2001)

Yanayi: Akeva GoldSman

Tarihin rayuwar John Nash, da baiwa da Nobel Laurenate, ya fada cikin fim din Oscar-free of Ron Howard, amma da yawa cikakkun bayanai ba su dace da gaskiya ba. Nash wani schizophrenic ne, kamar yadda aka nuna a cikin fim, amma an gano cutar da yawa, daga baya fiye da yadda aka nuna a hoton. Mutane da yawa daga kewaye da aka ƙirƙira. Aurensa na farko da ɗa ya kasance a wanke makircin. Bayyanar cututtuka na cutar da ke yin wani sashi na fim ɗin ana jan hankali sosai.

"Shakespeare cikin soyayya" (1998)

Yanayi: Mark Norman da Tom Rempard

"Shakespeare" cikin soyayya baya da'awar gaskiya ne, ko da yake yana amfani da yawancin sunaye masu yawa, wurare, abubuwan da al'amura. Labarin ya ba da labarin William da VIOL da yadda abin da ke ƙauna soyayya soyayya ta hancepeare don rubuta "romeo da juliet", shahararrun aikinsa. Yawancin fim ne zato ne wanda ba zai iya karyata ba, amma na zamani na rubuce-rubuce "romeo da juliet", sannan kuma "dare goma sha biyu" ba daidai ba ne. Kuma Sarauniya Elizabeth ba za ta taba yin wasa a bayan gidajen ba, tabbas tabbas ba za ta zo ga jama'a a lokacin annobar bubonic ba.

"Fox mafarauta" (2014)

Yanayi: Max Max sopp da Dan Futterman

Labarin zakara na yaki dave schulz a gidan na kasar Miliyan Johpona. Mafi yawan da aka nuna, da bayyanar gwagwarmaya da kuma bayyanar da alaƙar da ke tsakanin Mark Schulz (Channing Tatum) da Duping Karella) da Dupe Karelle), wanda basu taba faruwa ba. Dujn ya kasance mai kusa ga Dave (Mark Ruffalo), mutumin da ya kashe shi a ƙarshe.

Kara karantawa