Ibihuha bijyanye no gutandukana kwabashakanye basubiye mu 2008, ariko bisa nkaho murumunawe Briz noneho yatwaye ibintu byose ayoboye. Noneho Jamie Linn ahura numucuruzi wimyaka 28 Jason Watson, naho Casey aragerageza gukurura umukobwa we nukuri nukuri kugirango abone amafaranga. Mama Casey yavuze ko niba ashaka umutekano w'imari, agomba kurwanira gereza na Jamie Lynn, ku buryo amwishyura. Ikigaragara ni uko umuryango we uzi neza ko Case ashobora kuba undi Kevin Feerline n'umurongo w'amafaranga akomeye y'amacumu, mu gihe yagumye papa mu rugo.
Ariko amacumu birashoboka cyane ko bamuhemba mu ntego kuruta kumwihanganira mubuzima bwe. Inkomoko iti: "Ntashobora kumuha ikintu icyo ari cyo cyose, Jamie Linn arashobora kandi yiteguye kwishyura Casey umubare runaka utagikora mubuzima bwa Maddie nto."
Muri icyo gihe, inshuti za Casey zishimangira ko yita ku mukobwa we. Ati: "Turabizi ko akunda cyane Maddy, we ubwe ntiyishimiye igitekerezo cy'uko iki kintu cyaje mu rukiko. Ariko amafaranga ni imbaraga zitera, afite intege nke iyo igeze kuri nyina, kandi amubwira gukora. Ni umuhungu witwa Mamenkin. "